Buttermilk Pie

There’s nothing as tastey as an old fashion Buttermilk Pie!  People tend to think it actually tastes like buttermilk but it doesn’t.  It’s VERY sweet and easy!

INGREDIENTS:

  • 1 refrigerated pie dough for single crust
  • 2 cups sugar
  • 1/4 flour
  • 3 eggs
  • 1 stick butter softened
  • 1 tsp vanilla
  • 3/4 cup buttermilk

DIRECTIONS:

Preheat oven to 350′.  Pierce pie crust with a fork all over, and prebake for 5 minutes.  Whisk remaining ingredients together and pour into pie crust; bake 50-60 minutes and till browned.   You need to let it sit, cool, and settle before eating:)  It’s hard to wait, I know!

TIP:  You can add a touch of butter and/or vanilla for a richer pie. 

MIXING TIME!

POUR INTO THE PIE SHELL TIME:)

And then eating time.  Now I had every intention on taking a picture of the finished pie but my kiddos dug into before I could the picture of the  whole pie!!!  Here is a slice though;)

Join The Discussion

*

 SUBSCRIBE TO GET UPDATES AND SPECIAL GIVEAWAYS JUST FOR BEING AN EMAIL SUBSCRIBER! 

Comments

  1. 1


    Anna says

    That’s a gorgeous slice.
    I just love buttermilk pie. Mmmm

  2. 2


    Lori says

    I LOVE it too! My oldest son could eat the whole thing in one sitting if we let him..lol.

  3. 3


    Heather says

    Mmmmm… I love buttermilk pie! My grandma used to make this all the time!

    Heather’s last blog post..Fight the Frump – Mood Boosters

  4. 4


    Melody says

    My husband has been bugging me for months to make him a Buttermilk pie! He’s not from the South, and had never heard of it, so guess what I’m doing tomorrow??

    Thanks for the recipe!

    Melody’s last blog post..Taking a break

  5. 5


    Charla says

    I would love to have a slice of your pie right now. My mother used to make buttermilk pies, and my grandmother, too. In fact, this was one of my mother’s very favorite pies. Oh, how I wish I could eat a piece of pie with her right now! I hope everyone appreciates the time they have with their parents, because when they’re gone… you miss them so much!

    Charla’s last blog post..Four Foods on Friday #25 Questions

  6. 6


    Charla says

    PS Lori, I read the Buttermilk Pie post before I read the one about your Dad. Your family will be in my prayers!

    Charla’s last blog post..Four Foods on Friday #25 Questions

  7. 7


    Dano says

    MMMMMMMMMMM I just love this pie!! MMMMMMMMMM

  8. 8


    Dano says

    MMMMMMMMMM I just LOVE this Pie !! MMMMMMMMMM

  9. 9


    mary says

    I love the simplicity!

  10. 10

    Oh my goodness…makes me want to go make my own right now! I love buttermilk pie!

    the sustainable backyards last blog post..the omnivore

  11. 11


    Munjean tappin says

    Yes I see the butter milk photos they look delicious!! I would love to try this recipe. It looks like a custard. I would never have thought that this recipe existed..

  12. 12


    Mary Briner says

    Very yummy looking! I love all the photos that show the steps.

  13. 13


    sarah says

    buttermilk pie. Yes there are pictures.

  14. 14


    sharon gray says

    The pie sounds wonderful and the pictures are a help for newbeees discovering cooking. Love new ideas that are simple! I’m a great cook wanna-be but with as much fun I’ve been having reading cook books and enjoying web sites, that’ll all be changing soon!!

  15. 15


    sharon gray says

    The pie sounds wonderful and the pictures are a help for newbeees discovering cooking. Love new ideas that are simple! I’m a great cook wanna-be but with as much fun I’ve been having reading cook books and enjoying web sites, that’ll all be changing soon!!

  16. 16


    Tania says

    Hello, I am new to your site and this pie looks fabulous. I have never tried a buttermilk pie, but I will be trying it soon.

  17. 17


    Amber says

    I was wondering if this is a 8 or 9 inch pie? I want to make it for Thanksgiving!

  18. 18


    Dano says

    To Amber… You asked if you should use a 8 or a 9 inch pie? I used a glass 9 inch pie pan. You will just love this pie and will be making it offten !!!

  19. 19


    kt says

    Kitchen Aid mixer spotted! kt

  20. 20


    NanoCrow says

    “O.o “…. Yes … it was very tasty, thank

    ambienbuy.net

  21. 21


    Jerry says

    Delicious!!! I want to taste it…
    http://welcome-re.ru/

  22. 22


    Kelly Lance says

    It is good but the recipe i have is really sweet