Thing 1 and Thing 2 Nutter Butter Treats
Author: Lori
  • Nutter Butter Cookies
  • Wilton White Candy Melts
  • Wilton Red Candy Melts
  • Blue Cotton Candy
  • Black Candy Decorating Pen
  • Candy Eyes
  • Wax Paper
  1. Melt the red candy melts according to package directions. Coat half of each cookie with red candy melts and set on wax paper to harden.
  2. Meanwhile, melt the white candy melts according to package instructions. Using the melted white candy, make small circles on the wax paper. You'll need one for each cookie. Allow to harden completely.
  3. Once the red candy melts are hardened, dip the other half of each cookie in the white candy melts. Immediately add blue cotton candy to the top of the white section for hair for the "things." Set on wax paper to harden.
  4. Add candy eyes to the white section. Place one candy eye upside down for a nose.
  5. Remove the candy circles from the wax paper and turn over so the smooth side faces up. Using the candy decorating pen, write "Thing 1" or "Thing 2" for each cookie. Affix these circles to the front of the marshmallow pops using a dab of white candy melts.
  6. Package as desired, and enjoy!
  7. NOTE: The cotton candy is very fragile -- it will come off the cookies easily. Handle with care.
Recipe by A Cowboy's Wife at